The decision made by the Paris Magistrates' Court - Tribunal d'instance de Paris –on 22nd January 2013, pronounced its verdict on the appeal, exempting from penalty Apur (legal person) and Francis Rol-Tanguy (natural person), Director of Apur at the time of the events which concerned hours worked daily and weekly exceeding the maximum number permitted, during the year 2010. The decision of the court renders null the heavy penalty of fines announced at the first hearing (222,000 Euros for Apur, 50,000 Euros for Francis Rol-Tanguy).